What's An Umpire?
An umpire in insurance claim appraisals serves as a neutral third party responsible for resolving disputes between the insured (policyholder) and the insurer (insurance company) when they cannot agree on the value or extent of a claim. The umpire plays a crucial role in the appraisal process and ensures that a fair and impartial settlement is reached. Here's what an umpire does in insurance claim appraisals:
​
Selection: The selection of an umpire typically occurs when the insured and the insurer cannot agree on the value of a loss. Both parties may select their appraisers, and these appraisers may then select an umpire to help resolve further dispute.
Impartiality: The umpire must be impartial and unbiased, with no vested interest in favor of either the insured or the insurer. Their primary responsibility is to reach a fair and unbiased decision.
Examination of the Dispute: The umpire reviews all relevant information and documents related to the insurance claim dispute. This may include policy documents, damage assessments, repair estimates, and any other pertinent information.
Site Inspection: In some cases, the umpire may conduct a site inspection of the property or asset in question. This is to assess the extent of the damage, the cause of the loss, and other factors that may influence the appraisal.
​
Facilitating Discussions: The umpire helps facilitate discussions between the insured's appraiser and the insurer's appraiser. They may chair meetings or conferences where the two appraisers present their findings and arguments.
​
Determining the Appraisal Amount: If the insured's appraiser and the insurer's appraiser cannot reach an agreement, the umpire steps in to make a binding decision on the amount of the loss. This decision is known as the "umpire's award."
Issuing the Umpire's Award: The umpire's award is a formal document outlining the agreed-upon resolution. It specifies the monetary value of the loss, which both the insured and the insurer are legally bound to accept. This award is binding and final, resolving the dispute.
Documentation: The umpire ensures that the umpire's award and all relevant documents are properly prepared and signed by both appraisers and themselves. This documentation is crucial for the legal and contractual aspects of the claim settlement.
Communication: Throughout the process, the umpire communicates with both the insured and the insurer, as well as their respective appraisers, to keep all parties informed and to ensure a smooth resolution.
Completion: Once the umpire's award is issued and accepted by both parties, the appraisal process is considered complete, and the insurer is obligated to pay the agreed-upon amount to the insured, thereby resolving the claim dispute.
In summary, an umpire in insurance claim appraisals acts as an impartial decision-maker, overseeing the dispute resolution process and ensuring that a fair and binding settlement is reached when the insured and the insurer cannot agree on the value of a claim.